Authentic Millionaire’s Shortbread, or Caramel Shortcake, as it’s sometimes called, is a classic Scottish treat. Why make a faux version of this recipe when you can make this authentic Scottish version?
Originally published January 23, 2014
If you have a sweet tooth, or know someone who does, then this authentic Millionaire’s Shortbread is sure to be a recipe you’ll want to try.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
I’ve seen lots of recipes for what is supposed to be Millionaire’s Shortbread, but they simply don’t make the cut. In fact, one of the top recipes from a google search brings up a recipe which is called “Millionaire’s Shortbread”.
Authentic Scottish Shortbread made with 3 ingredients.
However, the shortbread shouldn’t have 7 ingredients in it. The caramel shouldn’t have corn syrup in it, and the chocolate topping isn’t just chocolate, but a ganache and it’s topped with salt. JUST NO. I’m not saying the recipe is bad, I’m saying it’s not Millionaire’s Shortbread.
This is a simpler, more “well-adjusted” shortbread recipe, because the shortbread is, well–actually shortbread. Why call something a peanut butter and jelly sandwich when there’s no peanut butter in it? It makes no sense. This recipe comes from Melanie Andrews, a Scottish baker and tea room owner for over 25 years in Helensburgh, Scotland. How much better can you get?
It’s my duty as a Scot to let you know things like this about mangled Scottish recipes, the same as I do when I find ridiculous recipes pretending to be “Italian”.
These Millionaire’s shortbread bars are great in lunch boxes, for bake sales, cookie exchanges, holiday gifts and so much more. They keep well for more than a week if they’re kept in an airtight tin.
Millionaire’s Shortbread aka Caramel Shortcake
slightly adapted recipe by Melanie Andrews
printable recipes below
Make the shortbread base
Make the caramel.
Spread the caramel on the shortbread base and cool.
Top with good quality melted chocolate.
When cool, cut into bars.
You know this isn’t the last time you’re going to make these, right?
Preheat oven to 350º F (170º C) Make the Shortbread Make the Caramel Finish the barsAuthentic Millionaire's Shortbread or Caramel Shortcake (Shortbread with Caramel and Chocolate)
Ingredients
Caramel Layer
Instructions
Nutrition Information:
Yield:
20
Serving Size:
1 bar
Amount Per Serving:Calories: 256 Total Fat: 13g Saturated Fat: 8g Trans Fat: 0g Unsaturated Fat: 4g Cholesterol: 32mg Sodium: 106mg Carbohydrates: 32g Fiber: 0g Sugar: 30g Protein: 3g
How to Make Shortbread and The Scottish Baking Awards 2014
Ingredients
- 2 1/4 cups (12 oz) all purpose flour
- 1/2 cup (4 oz) sugar
- 1 cup or 2 sticks (8 oz) butter, softened
- a little extra sugar for sprinkling on top of baked shortbread
Instructions
Heat oven to 375º F (190 ºC)
Mix all the ingredients together by hand or mixer, to a stiff dough.
- Roll out into fingers, shape into a round and score into triangle shapes, or press into a 7"x10" tray or press into a shortbread mold (brush the mold with a little oil, and sugar first).
- If your shortbread doesn't have a pretty design, prick it with a fork.
- Place in preheated oven for 25 to 30 minutes or until slightly brown on edges.
- Sprinkle with sugar immediately upon removing from the oven.
- Let cool on tray before moving to rack to cool completely.
Nutrition Information:
Yield:
8Serving Size:
1 pieceAmount Per Serving:Calories: 389 Total Fat: 24g Saturated Fat: 15g Trans Fat: 1g Unsaturated Fat: 7g Cholesterol: 61mg Sodium: 188mg Carbohydrates: 41g Fiber: 1g Sugar: 13g Protein: 4g
Christina’s Cucina is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.
I made this recipe 2 days ago and it’s amazing, hard to stop eating! I followed the recipe as written, using my kitchen scale to get the correct weights on the ingredients. I did have to add a bit of extra butter (between 1-2 TBS) to the shortbread dough because it was too crumbly. It might depend on the quality of flour being used. I was using grocery store brand all-purpose unbleached flour. Thanks for the recipe, this was the first of yours I tried and I’ll have to try some of the others now!
That’s great, Liz! Yes, if you weighed it, it could possibly be the flour you used. It is quite addictive :) I’m so happy you’ll be trying other recipes. Thank you so much for the review and note – I appreciate it much more than you know! CC
I just had this for the first time when I was in the UK this fall, so I couldn’t wait to try making it. ..but I really messed it up. I only had a glass pan and the shortbread stuck – should I have greased the pan? Also, my shortbread was crumbly and fell apart. The caramel sauce never changed color, even though I cooked it for half an hour stirring constantly. It was really sticky, so maybe I overcooked it? I used it anyway, but on the finished product you couldn’t even tell there was a caramel layer. The only thing I did right was the chocolate layer on top! ;) Can you advise me on where I went wrong? I’m determined to try again. Thanks!
Oh I’m so sorry, Christy. It’s no fun when recipes don’t turn out, but maybe I can help. ‘
First of all, I don’t believe the shortbread should have stuck to the glass pan, but if that’s all you have to use, try buttering it, lining it in parchment or waxed paper and then put in the shortbread. I bet the shortbread was crumbly if you didn’t use a scale (that’s my #1 suggestion for getting recipes right) to measure the flour and sugar? I bet there’s too much flour. If I could get away with removing cups on all of my recipes, I would. They are simply not accurate in baking (fine for cooking as it’s not scientific).
When you say that you can’t tell there’s a caramel layer is it because there wasn’t much to pour on? Maybe you did overcook it? You’ve got the chocolate down, so that’s good! Nancy Birtwhistle posted a video of my recipe yesterday, and maybe it will help you.
Let me know how it turns out next time, and I hope it is good! :)
How can you go wrong with this? Shortbread, caramel and CHOCOLATE! Hear, hear to real ingredients!
Right?! :)
Looks so good, and I never realized it was Scottish before! My Scottish ancestors never shared their recipe if they had one!
They held out on you, David! Haha! :)
I really want to make these! I’ll have to figure out a GF crust for my son, which will of course make them less authentic, BUT with your caramel and perfect melted chocolate,v they will still be delicious, I bet. And LOVED reading the above comment about how you travel so much. I get Scott’s emails everyday b/c of you. (Still waiting for my Madrid deal!) :-)
Dear Cristina, I have been making the Millionaire’s shortbread for years and found that if you cook the filling in the microwave on high power, (in a large bowl) it will cook up in about 5 minutes and will never scorch. Just stir it down every minute or so and it could not be more fool proof. I make it in a 9″ cake pan, , put it on a cake board and seal it with plastic wrap and tie a plaid ribbon on it. I makes for a very attractive and delicious gift. If you accidentally overcook the caramel and the butter separates, just stir in a bit of hot water and it will be fine.
I love your travels, it brings back wonderful memories.
Thanks for sharing that tip, Juley! I’m sure some readers will like to know this, too! You sound like a real pro and the gift with the tartan ribbon sounds like a winner! How lovely! I’m so glad you enjoy my travel posts :) More to come in 2019! Merry Christmas!
I love caramel shortbread bars! I’ve made these before (not with your recipe) and wasn’t entirely happy with it, so I’m excited to try these. One question, though, before I start… when you say ‘condensed milk’, do you mean sweetened condensed milk, or evaporated milk (US terminology)? I know there is a difference in what the two are called in the UK and the US.
P.S.- I’ve just booked a flight to Scotland for April into May through Scott’s Cheap Flights, staying for four weeks! I’m going solo but have friends in Edinburgh. I’ll use that as my base, then travel some around the country. It’s a little off-season so it was a good price from Dallas. I’m definitely a budget traveler! I love seeing your travel adventures.
Hi Carol, yes, condensed milk as in sweetened condensed milk (it needs to be thick). So happy to hear you’re going to Scotland! To be honest, you’re going at one of the best times. Last year, I was there the whole month of May (Scotland and England) and got the best weather! Think I pulled out my umbrella once! Nothing wrong with budget travel, I’ve done it most of my life and still do, although I’m treating myself a bit more in my “old age” haha! Merry Christmas and Happy New Year! CC
Putting these on my holiday baking list.
You’re a gem! Happy baking!
This will never last in my house! My husband was drooling over the picture. It will call his name in the middle of the night.
Haha! That’s funny! Good luck, Katie! :)
Hi Christina. I always enjoy reading about your travels, but I have a question. How in the world can you afford all these trips? I certainly can’t seem to travel, even though I’d love to. What is your secret? I’m asking because I want to know what I need to do to travel or what I’ve been doing wrong all my life.
Thanks.
Hi Shirley, excellent question! Since I saved up my babysitting money for my first solo overseas trip when I was 17, I have made travel a priority in my life. I know that many people say they’d love to travel, but just don’t have the money. For example, when I was a social worker and made very little, I still found cheap flights and always had some trip (even if it was a weekend away an hour away) planned to look forward to. My colleague always complained that she couldn’t travel as I did (even though her salary was more than mine). The difference was I prioritized travel, and she didn’t. She spent loads of money on eating out, getting her nails and hair done frequently, going to the movies, full-service gas (that was still available!) and other things I didn’t do.
Now, I use Scott’s Cheap Flights/Travelzoo to find great deals for airfare ($299 to Barcelona last year, $400 to New Zealand and I just booked a flight for Paris for $298 -these are all round trip from LA). Sometimes I do stay with family or am hosted by tourism boards, but honestly, I just work hard and research places and choose to spend $ traveling versus other things most people do (NEVER spend a penny at Starbucks) :) AirBnB is another option for accommodation. My daughter just booked a trip for spring break to go to Barcelona and Porto and when splitting the accommodation with friends is paying $16/night in Portugal. Where there’s a will there’s a way! Hope this helps, Shirley! :)
I’ve never had this, but it would be fun to make with my granddaughters this week. Thanks for the recipe. It looks yummy and not too hard to do.
That would be a great baking project because it isn’t too difficult, Shirley. I’m sure they’d love the end result, too! Enjoy!
This reminds me of being a child at Christmas when my Mum always used to make it! My mincemeat Bakewell tart from your recipe was a winner on Monday btw!
Awesome, Suzanne! So glad you enjoyed the Bakewell Tart, too! Thank you!